Update the Old Posts Before You Write New Ones

Post Image

Person editing a blog post in a website editor on a laptop

We went through our own blog this year. There were 215 posts going back years, and a fair few of them made us wince. Posts with 2021 in the web address. A Google update from 2022 explained as though it were news. Close to twenty groups of articles all chasing the same search and getting in each other’s way.

So before writing anything new, we started on the old ones. It’s the least glamorous job in SEO. For a site with a few years behind it, it also tends to pay back faster than any new article will.

Why old posts hold a site back

Three things happen to a blog that only ever grows.

Posts go stale. A 2019 article quoting 2019 prices tells a reader, and Google, that nobody’s minding the shop.

Posts overlap and Google has to choose one to show. Often it picks the weakest, or keeps swapping between them so none of them settle.

And the good ones get buried. Your three best articles end up sitting in a pile of 150, linked from nowhere.

AI search has raised the stakes. The tools writing answers above the search results lean on content that’s current and specific, so an out of date post is less likely to be quoted. If it does get quoted, you’d probably rather it hadn’t.

Sort every post into four piles

Open Google Search Console, set the date range to the last 12 months and export every blog address with its clicks, impressions and average position. That spreadsheet makes most of the decisions for you.

  • Keep. Still accurate and still bringing in clicks. Leave it alone.
  • Refresh. Plenty of impressions but few clicks, or sitting somewhere between position 8 and 20. Google already half likes these. They’re the gold.
  • Merge. Two or three posts on the same subject. Pick the strongest and fold the best of the others into it.
  • Remove. No clicks, no impressions, no links pointing at it and nothing in it worth rescuing.

One check before anything lands in the remove pile. Has it ever brought in an enquiry, and do other websites link to it? A post with twelve visits a year that produced two jobs beats one with 2,000 visits and none.

What a proper refresh involves

Changing the publish date doesn’t count. Google’s own guidance warns against updating the date to look fresh when the content hasn’t changed.

Start with the search itself. Look up the phrase the post is meant to rank for and read what’s on the first screen today. The question people are asking may have shifted since you wrote it.

Then fix what’s wrong. Prices, screenshots, dead links, tools that no longer exist, anything that says “this year” and means 2022. Move the answer up so it sits in the first two paragraphs and not the sixth. Add what you’ve learned since, because a job you finished last winter is better evidence than a paragraph of general advice. The same thinking sits behind getting a website ready for AI search.

Keep the web address the same wherever you can. That address is where the post’s history lives.

Last, send the reader somewhere useful. A refreshed article on bathroom renovation costs should point to the bathroom renovation service, and that service needs to be worth landing on. We’ve covered that end of it in service content that ranks and converts.

Merging and removing without breaking anything

When you merge, each losing post needs a 301 redirect to the winner. That carries its history across, and anyone following an old link still lands somewhere sensible.

When you remove, redirect to the closest relevant article if there is one. If there isn’t, let the address return a proper “gone” response. Sending everything to the homepage is the shortcut to avoid, because Google treats it as a dead end and so do visitors.

Then check your own links. Delete a post that five others link to and you’ve left five broken links behind.

Where to start, and how fast to go

Begin with the refresh pile, sorted by impressions. Those posts already have Google’s attention, so an improvement often shows within weeks. A brand new article can wait months for the same notice.

Merges come second. Removals go last, because they’re the easiest to get wrong.

For a small business, two or three old posts a month is a sensible pace, alongside whatever new writing you’re doing. We’d take that over ten new articles nobody reads.

It’s also the order we work in on any SEO campaign in Auckland or elsewhere in the country. Audit first, write second. Send us your blog address and we’ll tell you which pile most of it belongs in.

Prev
No more posts
Next
One Website or a Separate Site for Each Branch?
Comments are closed.